ESIC chief Ian Smith speaks on CSGO cheat forsaken's ban


ESIC chief Ian Smith has described the five-year ban for CSGO cheat forsaken as "right and in proportion".

Nikhil 'forsaken' Kumawat was banned from all esports-related activity for five years after cheating during the ESL India Premiership last month.

The ban imposed by ESIC - the Esports Integrity Coalition - came after the player was also caught cheating during the eXTREMESLAND 2018 Asia Finals.

Some fans felt a five-year ban was too lenient for the 23-year-old pro but ESIC integrity commissioner Smith described the decision as "right".

Speaking as a guest on The Luckbox Podcast, he said: "Yes cheating is abhorrent and I completely understand the community's reaction but five years in the context of traditional sports sanctions for cheating is actually very harsh.

"A lifetime ban is up there with major match-fixing scandals, second offences and third offences.

"You could have steroided yourself to the gills and won an Olympic gold medal in the 100m men's final and you would not get banned for doing that if it was your first offence, for as long as we have banned forsaken for using a software hack.

"So I'm comfortable that we've got this right and in proportion.

"I have tremendous sympathy for the community's desire to punish these people but it's not my job to enforce mob rule, it's my job to be reasonable, proportionate and follow due process.

"At the end of the day do what's right for esports and, in my view, five years is right."

The Luckbox podcast is available on YouTube, Soundcloud, Spotify and iTunes.

James McMathMedia manager at Luckbox.

Related Articles

13 hours ago
2 days ago
3 days ago
4 days ago
When it comes to Counter-Strike, there are some names you know you can rely on. S1mple, for example, can be reliably expected to drop the sort of numbers most people would put on their bedroom wall on a daily basis. Coldzera will always do the right thing in any situation, and xyp9x is going to win the next clutch as sure the sun will rise tomorrow. Likewise, there are some names you hear from a talent point of view and know instantly its going to be a good show, and none more so than Duncan...
After his removal from North and subsequent move to North America, Danish in-game leader Mathias MSL Lauridsen has had a quiet few weeks, but he came back with a bang in an interview given to leading CSGO coverage site In it, the 23-year old talks about North, and his removal, as well as the way his future in NA might unfold, in a fashion that has confused some of those who watched his team over the last few years. It is impossible to know what goes on behind the scenes, of course, but...
Talent development in sports or esports will always be a crucial part of the ecosystem, and today we have more than ever coming through in the top tier of CSGO. Across Europe there are exciting new players emerging, from France to Sweden and beyond, and the same is true in the growing Asian scene, too. South America, NA, wherever you look there are killers abound, but for some reason there is one position with a real dearth of top-end options in the greatest gun game going, that of the in...
IEM Chicago 2018 features 16 top CSGO teams battling it out for a share of a $250 prize pool at the Wintrust Arena. It is the final tourmanent of the Intel Extreme Masters season before IEM Katowice in February 2019. IEM Chicago schedule Final (BO5) Sunday, November 11th 8pm: Team Liquid 0-3 Astralis IEM Chicago live Twitch stream IEM Chicago live stream is available via Twitch. IEM Chicago results Latest CSGO results Semi-finals (BO3) Saturday, November 10th (Times in UTC / GMT) FaZe 1-2 Team...
The Luckbox Podcast: Thorin special
The curious case of MSLs HLTV interview
All CSGO wants for Christmas is some IGLs
IEM Chicago 2018 schedule, results and Twitch stream
IEM Chicago: NiKo, king of FaZe, flexes on Astralis